Thursday, February 26, 2015

Do Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence Jury Response

Being a part of the jury was quite an experience. Seeing the intense debate between the two sides was very entertaining and it was extremely difficult to side with only one of them. In the end, the pro side won my vote through the use of their clear and effective evidence and analysis. All of the presenters were very persuasive. As soon as I thought I had made my mind up on whose side to choose, someone brought up a piece of evidence that made me totally change my mind. Everyone did an amazing job at presenting and made me change my stance about ten different times throughout the duration of the trial. Their confidence and knowledge of the topic really shined through, especially Christine and Bobby's, which made it feel like we were in an actual court room with real lawyers. Christine, Lucy, and Caroline's PowerPoint was very organized and made it easy to take notes and get all of the information down, whereas it was the opposite for the opposition. The pro side's evidence, such as the study on the brain connected to video games was very helpful and really convincing. Also, their story about the Slenderman game was scary, and brought how these video games really do contribute to youth violence to life. The opposition commented about how they have heard the Slenderman story about one hundred times, but I would rather hear about something I am somewhat familiar with, then get a bunch of different video game names thrown at me and not able to digest them all before they move on to the next piece of evidence. The con side presented a graph that they said showed how as the sales of violent video games went up, the homicide rate stayed the same. The pro side poked at this in their rebuttle, stating that they presented their evidence incorrectly, and that the graph really showed how as the sales of violent video games went up, so did the homicide rates. With all that being said, the con side did bring in some good evidence as well. They stated that video games cannot be used as the only cause of youth violence, since that is not the case. This really made me think, and almost made me change my mind. Also, they said that some video games had settings that you can change the levels of violence if you want it to be less or more violent and this piece of evidence helped their case. One of their catagories was how the children's parents can control what they are playing, but this is completely false. Kids have older brothers and sisters that they can steal video games from, their parents can buy the games without knowing that they are as violent as the are, and some parents simply don't care.  They also said that the average age of players was thirty five, which I found very surprising. What I didn't find effective, was how in the closing argument, the con side was contradicting themselves and were being really confusing. The pro side was the exact opposite. They really sold their case well and convinced me with out a doubt that violent video games do in fact contribute to youth violence. 

No comments:

Post a Comment