Friday, October 17, 2014

Dialectical journal

Alana White
Mr. Beattie
Honors English 1
14 October 2014
​​​A Raisin in the Sun Dialectical Journal

Ruth: What kind of eggs you want?
Walter: Not scrambled
(Ruth starts to scramble eggs)
Ruth: Paper come? Set another bomb off yesterday.
(p.26)
(R/P) This excerpt from the play shows that Walter and Ruth are very comfortable with each other. They have been together for so long and it is just second nature to Ruth not to listen to Walter. She asks him what kind of eggs he wants, but she doesn’t really mean what she is saying because she makes him the same type of eggs every day. They have an extremely close bond and obviously care about each other, but are both so tired and worn out to really show their affection towards each other. This can, and often does, happen to couples everywhere. People nowadays just want to survive; they don’t live life to the fullest. They go through the motions of the day and have a set schedule that seems to repeat itself infinitively. They forget the meaning of love and why they even got married to their spouse in the first place. They work their whole entire lives and become worn out. They think there isn’t enough time and energy to show affection. Sadly, this is reality and it happens to a lot of couples. After a while, they just sort of give up on love and just try to survive on what they have. I predict that by the end of the play, Ruth and Walter will still be together, but still have a depressing relationship. They will stay together for the sake of their family, even though they are not truly happy.
Mama: (Kindly) ‘Course you going to be a doctor, honey, God willing.
Beneatha: (Drily) God hasn’t got a thing to do with it.
Mama: Beneatha- that wasn’t necessary.
Beneatha: Well-neither is God. I get sick of hearing about God
Mama: Beneatha!
Beneatha: I mean it! I’m just tired of hearing about God all the time. What has He got to do with anything? Does he pay tuition?
Mama: You ‘bout to get your fresh little jaw slapped!
Ruth: That’s just what she needs, all right!
Beneatha: Why? Why cant I say what to I want around here, like everybody else?
Mama: It don’t sound nice for a young girl to say things like that-you wasn’t brought up that way. Me and your father went to trouble to get you and Brother to church every Sunday.
Beneatha: Mama, you don’t understand. Its all a matter of ideas, and God is just one idea I don’t accept. It’s not important. I am not going out and be immoral or commit crimes because I don’t believe in God. I don’t even think about it. Its just that I get tired of Him getting credit for all the things the human race achieves through its own stubborn effort. There is simply no blasted God-there is only man and it is he who makes miracles.
(p. 50-51)








(C) When I read this passage, I immediately though of conversations that my mom and I have had recently about this topic. At this point in my life, I am still trying to find myself and I’m still so young and have a whole world ahead of me. I believe that there is something to believe in-but I’m not sure what quite yet. Whether it is God, or another higher power, that is something that I have yet to decide. I’m fine with my parents and sister believing in God, but I hate when they try to shove the Catholic religion down my throat. Why go through ten years of Sunday school just to realize at the end of it that you actually don’t believe in anything that the teacher is saying. I have the same feeling as Beneatha because my parents just don’t understand. It isn’t like I’m trying to rebel against them or anything; it’s just that I haven’t found what I believe in just yet. With that being said, I do think I will find it someday. It is something that comes with time and experience, not someone forcing you to go to church and Sunday school.  
George: What have you done to your head-I mean your hair!
Beneatha: Nothing-except cut it off.
Ruth: Now that’s the truth-its what ain't been done to it! You expect this boy to go out with you with you head all nappy like that?
Beneatha: That’s up to George. If he’s ashamed of his heritage-
George: Oh, don’t you be so proud of yourself, Bennie-just because you look eccentric.
Beneatha: How can something that’s natural be eccentric?
(p.88)
(E) When Beneatha cuts off her hair to look more African American and “natural”, she is mostly doing it for Asagai. He has influenced her to almost become a changed person that is very in touch with her heritage. It is incredibly clear that George hates Beneatha’s new look, and doesn’t think that her hair should look so poufy and crazy. He likes it better when it is flat and non-African American looking. Through Beneatha changing her hairstyle, the author is trying to show that Beneatha is also changing. With her hair getting bigger and bolder, so are her personality, her dreams, her mindset, and her overall way of life.
Walter: (To Ruth without thinking) Who’s fighting you? Who even cares about you?
(p.87)
Walter and Ruth’s relationship has taken a turn for the worse. They are dealing with a dysfunctional relationship that is seriously not working out for them. In the beginning of the play, they at least had a bit of humor in their relationship and tried to bring out the good sides of each other, but that is not the case anymore. Of course, they still loveeach other, but the situation with Mama not givingWalter his money for the liquor store has put a damper on his mood and it is affecting everyone around him. Walter probably doesn’t mean what he is saying, but he just says it out of anger because of all the other stress her has going on in his life.
Beneatha: It used to be so important to me. I wanted to cure. It used to matter. I used to care.
(p.133)
(C) This is my biggest fear in life. I am one who tends to give up easily if I loose even the littlest bit of hope. I want to become a dermatologist one day and there is just so much work and money involved that I feel as if I am not ready to take on all of that pressure. This is because there is always a chance of failure. I know, and am still trying to accept, that sometimes failure is a good thing. We don’t always win in life, and failing can teach us more valuable lessons than winning ever will. I connect to Beneatha’s feelings of having something that you really want to pursue, and are very passionate about it, but it just doesn’t seem like it is worth it.
Asagai: They who might kill me even… actually replenish all that I was.
(p.136)
(R/E/Q) The author was definitely trying to send a couple messages through this line. First off, by Asagai saying this, he is basically stating that people who try to bring him down, are actually those who bring him up and motivate him to work harder and prove them all wrong. This is a message to the world that no matter how clear it is that you are a dedicated, sincere, and pure person, there is always going to be a few people that try to bring you down and crush your dreams. But doesn’t that just make you better? They are simply motivators because they say that you can’t do something, but then you are even more motivated to succeed just to prove them wrong. The second message that the author was trying to send connected to Walter. Asagai and Beneatha are smart, hard working young adults with bright futures ahead of them. Walter is a middle-aged man, who chauffeurs and is living at his mother’s house with his wife and child. Jealousy plays a huge part in this. Asagai is the man that Walter wants to be. He will do anything to bring him down and make him not accomplish his goals. Asagai is too smart for this, and rather than letting it bring him down, he makes it a positive situation by letting Walter’s unkind words motivate him.
At curtain, there is a sullen light of gloom in the living room, gray light not unlike that which began the first scene of Act 1.
(p.131)
(Q) This setting creates a forlorn and depressing mood. Why did the author feel the need to connect the feeling back to Act 1? Is the family going to end up like they were in the beginning before the money was put in their hands, or will there be a plot twist and will the book have a happy ending?
Ruth: LETS GET THE HELL OUT OF HERE!
(p.149)
(E) Ruth is so excited that this day is finally here. Even if she didn’t directly say if because they money was none of her business in the first place and she had no right to tell Mama what/what not to do with it, her dream all along was to settle down in a good house with her family. All of the characters know that this is the best way to spend the money, because it is not selfish and not only one person gets the money for what they want. For example, if Walter spent all of the money on the liquor store and it failed, the family would be angry with him. But you cant be angry with a functioning household and somewhere that you can raise a family up in.



Thursday, October 9, 2014

Sitting "Benetha" Tree

A young girl sitting "Beneatha" tree
Wondering if she will ever break out of this pot that is holding her in
With so many dreams and wishes for her life
But they may not come true
All because of you

It is because of you
That she is inspired to defy society
It is because of you
That she wants to prove everyone wrong

But, it is also because of you
That she doubts herself and wants to give up
But, it is also because of you
That these dreams may not come true

The girl is so young and clueless
She wants to make a difference and leave her footprint on this Earth
She has been told that she will not make it, and that it is not even worth trying
And that is what inspires her to be different

As the young girl sits "Beneatha" tree, she wonders
If she will defy society,
Or will she crumble and let her dreams float away
With the leaves of the tree, into the crisp fall day?