Some people say that all books are always better than the movie. In this situation, I agree 100%. It is hard to make a 300 page book into only a two hour movie, so sometimes it is their only option to eliminate things. For example, one character that I found was very important but not included in the movie was Aunt Alexandria. I thought she was important because she was the one who basically forced Scout to change herself and to grow up. By listening in on her conversations with the town mission group, Scout learned things about people and the world that she had not known before. A scene that I really missed was Jem finding his first chest hair. This was a cute sibling moment in the book that didn't transfer to the movie and I think it should have. It would've added much needed humor, between the Tom Robinson case and Boo Radley. Another scene that I missed was when Calpurnia came into the courtroom during Toms's trial and got the kids. This added a great deal of drama and it would've been beneficial to include this in the movie.
Thursday, January 15, 2015
Things were both gained and lost by having the movie version of To Kill a Mockingbird not be in Scout's perspective, but I think that there were more things lost then gained. For example, we loose all of Scouts personal thoughts and opinions on things that we would not know otherwise. She sometimes thought things rather than saying them out loud, and it helped the reader to have a better comprehension of the situation and of her point of view. Another thing that we loose is the 'growing up' factor. In the novel, we can clearly tell by her thoughts, actions, and words that she is changing and evolving into a young lady, but in the movie, we can't. I think that one of the most important messages that Harper Lee was trying to send was empathy and growth, and that is totally nonexistent in the film, which changed one of the main ideas of the book. Readers loved watching Scout grow and change and learn things about the world from her experiences and weren't able to get it out of the movie. The thing that was gained by having the movie not be in Scout's perspective is that you get to see some of the things that Scout wasn't present for. Also, you can and hear see things first hand rather in a chain of gossip, like this person said to this person who told that person, so it is more clear and straight forward.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment